Cronkite Header

Cronkite News has moved to a new home at Use this site to search archives from 2011 to May 2015. You can search the new site for current stories.

Arizonans go for the gold – and platinum – in the health-care marketplace

Email this story
Print this story

WASHINGTON – Arizona residents are signing up for the Affordable Care Act’s top-shelf gold- and platinum-level insurance plans at some of the highest rates in the nation, new government figures show.

The Department of Health and Human Services reported this week that 41 percent of Arizonans who had enrolled under Obamacare by Dec. 28 had signed up for the gold or platinum plans. That compares to a national average of about 20 percent for those two plan levels.

The state’s residents are leaning toward the higher-priced plans even though they have been relatively lukewarm in general when it comes to enrolling for health care under the ACA.

The 27,943 Arizonans who were enrolled on Dec. 28 represent about 0.43 percent of the state’s 6.55 million residents, compared to a national enrollment rate of about 0.69 percent, according to the HHS data.

Pati Urias said affordability might be one reason Arizona residents are opting for the upper-end plans.

“Our plans are priced cheaper,” said Urias, the Arizona communications lead for Enroll America, a nonprofit that helps people sign up for health coverage available under the ACA.

Urias said Pima County has some of the lowest-cost policies in the country for health insurance plans. She added that competition is a huge factor, noting that some Arizonans have more than 100 plans they can choose from.

David Aguirre, health marketplace coordinator for the Greater Phoenix Urban League, said he could not point to any one reason for people selecting gold- or platinum-level plans. But he speculated that subsidies that are provided based on income and family size might make the higher-level plans affordable for some.

The HHS report, released Monday, said that Arizona had the lowest rate of individuals getting a subsidy for their insurance plan – at 68 percent – among states like Arizona where the insurance marketplaces are run or supported by the federal government.

Urias said the number of people in Arizona who qualify for financial assistance could have been reduced by the state’s relatively low premiums. But she noted that two-thirds of individuals enrolled is still a significant number.

Despite the higher intial cost, Urias said a gold- or platinum-level plan can help save money in the long run for people with recurring medical needs, because it provides more comprehensive coverage. Gold-level plans pay for 80 percent of covered costs, and platinum-level plans pay for 90 percent of covered costs.

The majority of individuals nationally – and 48 percent of Arizonans – selected silver-level plans, which pay for 70 percent of covered costs. But those plans come with lower premiums than gold- and platinum-level plans.

Only Massachusetts, North Dakota, Kentucky and the District of Columbia had higher shares of high-end plan purchasers than Arizona. In the District, 49 percent of enrollees opted for a gold or platinum plan, while 44 percent in Massachusetts did so and 42 percent of Kentuckians did.

North Dakota does not offer a platinum plan, but 44 percent of enrollees there opted for the top plan, gold.

In addition to platinum, gold and silver, the insurance marketplaces offer low-cost bronze-level plans, which cover 60 percent of costs, and bare-bones catastrophic coverage.