Skip to main content

Explore the cost shift

Infographic: how a Medicaid reimbursement cut changes urban and rural hospital margins. A complete text description follows.

Text version of the original hospital cost-shift infographic

Original model: each treatment costs the hospital $500 and is billed at $700. Medicaid pays 75 percent of cost; uninsured patients pay none; insured patients cover 100 percent of the charge. The graphic describes a goal of at least a 5 percent profit margin to maintain quality of care.

For 1,000 patients in the Maricopa County urban-hospital example, treatment costs $500,000. The patient mix is 16.5 percent Medicaid, 17.3 percent uninsured and 66.2 percent insured. Receipts are $61,875 from Medicaid, $0 from uninsured patients and $463,400 from insured patients. The graphic reports a 5 percent profit margin.

For 1,000 patients in the Navajo County rural-hospital example, treatment costs $500,000. The patient mix is 34.8 percent Medicaid, 16.7 percent uninsured and 48.5 percent insured. Receipts are $155,500 from Medicaid, $0 from uninsured patients and $339,500 from insured patients. The Medicaid figure includes an additional $25,000 in financial assistance. The graphic reports a 1 percent deficit.

After an AHCCCS provider-reimbursement cut of 5 percent, the graphic shows Medicaid paying 71.25 percent of cost. With the same patient mix and costs, the urban example receives $58,781 from Medicaid and $463,400 from insured patients, reducing its reported profit margin to 4.4 percent.

The rural example receives $148,975 from Medicaid, including the additional $25,000 financial assistance, and $339,500 from insured patients. Its reported deficit increases to 2.3 percent.

Original source credited in the graphic: U.S. Census Bureau American Community Survey, 2008–2010. Graphic by Tarryn Mento. These are the archived graphic’s figures and assumptions, not current hospital finances.

Email this story
Print this story