Skip to content

Federal officials refuse endangered species protection to cactus pygmy-owl

WASHINGTON–The U.S Fish and Wildlife Service refused to grant threatened- or endangered-species status Wednesday to the cactus ferruginous pygmy-owl, even though there may be fewer than 50 of the birds left in the state.

The service said that while the population of owls in Arizona may be scarce, the bird occurs in more than eight states in Mexico where it is commonly spotted.

"As you move south through its range, it becomes far more common," said Jeff Humphrey, a spokesman for the wildlife service.

But conservation groups warned that the government's failure to protect the bird would eventually wipe out the entire population of pygmy-owls in Arizona.

"With the development in Tucson, the rest of its natural habitat will be gone without the protection," said Gregory S. Butcher, director of bird conservation for the national Audubon Society.

The Fish and Wildlife Service says the owl is reddish-brown with a cream-colored belly and yellow eyes. The birds do not have ear tufts and are marked by relatively long tails and eye spots on the backs of their heads. They only measure 6 to 7 inches long and typically nest in cactus cavities.

Its range extends from central and southern Arizona south through Sonora and Sinaloa, Mexico.

A Defenders of Wildlife fact sheet on the bird says their numbers have been declining for years. "Since 1996, authorities in Arizona have found anywhere from 12-41 adult pygmy owls a year, and in 2006, surveyors spotted only 28 owls," it said.

The Federal Register notice on the bird Wednesday said recent surveys in Pima and Maricopa counties and in the Barry M. Goldwater Range have failed to find any owls in their historic range, "strong evidence that the current range of the pygmy-owl in Arizona has contracted."

The owls were listed as endangered once before, but that designation was lifted in 2006 in the face of a lawsuit by the National Association of Home Builders. Environmental groups petitioned in March 2007 to have the birds listed again.

The Fish and Wildlife Service issued its decision on that petition Wednesday, saying that listing the bird again is not warranted.

Humphrey said that one element in the decision was the fact that there has never been a large population of the owls in the U.S. in the first place.

"It is safe to say, the pygmy owl had never been an abundant bird in the U.S. and it is a rare bird today," he said.

But Noah Greenwald, endangered species director at the Center for Biological Diversity, said the pygmy owl should be listed. The center was one of the groups petitioning to have the owls protected again.

"There is no question that the (pygmy) owl in the desert is clearly endangered," he said.

Greenwald said Wednesday's decision is not the end of the fight as far as his center is concerned.

"We are quite disappointed, we are going to challenge it in federal court," he said.

Butcher said the alternative is that Arizona will no longer have the pygmy owls if they stay unprotected.

"I think it is very likely that this segment of the species will disappear," he said.

The ferruginous cactus pygmy-owl is found in Pima and Maricopa counties, parts of Texas and through much of Mexico.
The ferruginous cactus pygmy-owl is found in Pima and Maricopa counties, parts of Texas and through much of Mexico.

Bob Miles, Arizona Game and Fish Department

The ferruginous cactus pygmy-owl is relatively rare in the United States, but the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service ruled this week that the 6- to 7-inch birds are not endangered.
The ferruginous cactus pygmy-owl is relatively rare in the United States, but the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service ruled this week that the 6- to 7-inch birds are not endangered.

Tom Gatz, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service