Skip to content

Senate Ethics Committee votes to investigate complaint against Bundgaard

PHOENIX – The Senate Ethics Committee voted Tuesday to investigate a complaint against state Sen. Scott Bundgaard, R–Peoria, in connection with a roadside altercation involving his former girlfriend.

"The bottom line in this is, was this conduct unbecoming of a legislator?" said Sen. Leah Landrum Taylor, D–Phoenix, one of three members who voted to proceed. "And as I look at all the information … I can only say yes."

Sen. Steve Gallardo, D–Phoenix, lodged the ethics complaint, saying that the February incident along State Route 51 was improper conduct that could adversely affect the Senate.

Witnesses said Bundgaard pulled Aubry Ballard out of his parked car and threw her to the ground. Bundgaard denied wrongdoing but pleaded no contest last month to a misdemeanor charge of reckless endangerment and was ordered to complete a domestic–violence program.

"We have one of our own, a member of the state Senate, that was involved in a domestic–violence situation," Gallardo said at a news conference after the hearing. "And it is up to us, senators, to hold our members accountable."

Bundgaard, who was removed as Senate majority leader because of the controversy, didn't attend the hearing.

The panel voted 3–1 in favor of an investigation, with Ethics Committee Chairman Ron Gould, R–Lake Havasu City, and Sen. Steve Yarbrough, R–Chandler joining Landrum Taylor.

Senate Majority Leader Andy Biggs, R–Gilbert, said he voted against moving forward because the case is still pending in court.

"I think that we are here prematurely," Biggs said.

Mark Goldman, an attorney for Bundgaard, noted that the senator must still meet the requirements of his plea agreement.

"This matter is not fully and finally adjudicated and will only be fully and finally adjudicated upon Senator Bundgaard's conclusion of his courses in agreement with the court's order," he told the committee.

In return for Bundgaard's plea, prosecutors dropped a misdemeanor assault charge. He would face jail time and probation if he fails to complete the diversion program within a year.

The committee agreed to meet again Sept. 20 to discuss how to proceed with its investigation.

Gould said he doesn't know how long the process will take, as the committee doesn't conduct ethics hearings often.

"The whole thing's unplowed ground," Gould said.

Goldman said "political overtones" were to blame for Tuesday's vote but declined to elaborate. He said Bundgaard will welcome the investigation because it will allow him to tell his side of the story.

"I am disappointed, but I'm not surprised one bit," Goldman said.

Four weeks ago state Sen. Scott Bundgaard pleaded no contest to a misdeameanor charge stemming with an altercation with a former girlfriend along a Valley freeway. The Senate Ethics Committee has now decided to investigate an ethics complaint in which a fellow lawmaker alleges that Bundgaard's actions could adversely affect the Senate. Cronkite News reporter Matthew Trotter has the story.
Four weeks ago state Sen. Scott Bundgaard pleaded no contest to a misdeameanor charge stemming with an altercation with a former girlfriend along a Valley freeway. The Senate Ethics Committee has now decided to investigate an ethics complaint in which a fellow lawmaker alleges that Bundgaard's actions could adversely affect the Senate. Cronkite News reporter Matthew Trotter has the story.

Matthew Trotter

Open original media

(From left) Sen. Leah Landrum Taylor, D–Phoenix, Senate Majority Leader Andy Biggs, R-Gilbert, Ethics Committee Chaiman Ron Gould, R–Lake Havasu City, and Sen. Steve Yarbrough, R-Chandler, voted on whether to investigate a complaint against Bungaard.
(From left) Sen. Leah Landrum Taylor, D–Phoenix, Senate Majority Leader Andy Biggs, R-Gilbert, Ethics Committee Chaiman Ron Gould, R–Lake Havasu City, and Sen. Steve Yarbrough, R-Chandler, voted on whether to investigate a complaint against Bungaard.

Joanne Ingram

Sen. Steve Gallardo, D-Phoenix, stands alongside Elizabeth Ditlevson, deputy director of the Arizona Coalition Against Domestic Violence, at a news conference. Gallardo lodged the ethics complaint against Sen. Scott Bungaard, R-Peoria.
Sen. Steve Gallardo, D-Phoenix, stands alongside Elizabeth Ditlevson, deputy director of the Arizona Coalition Against Domestic Violence, at a news conference. Gallardo lodged the ethics complaint against Sen. Scott Bungaard, R-Peoria.

Joanne Ingram