Skip to content

Loughner returns to Tucson for hearing on competency

WASHINGTON – The legal standard for competency is straightforward, but the application of it to a defendant like Jared Lee Loughner is a far trickier matter, experts say.

"The competency standard is easy to meet," said Christopher Slobogin, director of the criminal justice program at Vanderbilt Law School. He said a court considers whether a defendant is "able to talk to an attorney, and is he able to understand the trial?"

"Just because people are mentally ill does not mean they are incompetent to stand trial," said Slobogin, who is also a professor of psychiatry.

That will be the challenge Wednesday for U.S. District Judge Larry Burns, who will be asked to determine if the government can continue to treat Loughner in an effort to make him competent for trial.

Loughner is charged with 49 counts in connection with a Jan. 8 Tucson shooting spree that killed six people, including 9–year–old Christina Green, and wounded Rep. Gabrielle Giffords and 12 others.

After his arrest, several doctors who examined Loughner found that he was delusional and suffered from paranoid schizophrenia. On May 25, Burns found Loughner mentally incompetent to stand trial and committed him for four months to a medical center at a federal prison in Springfield, Mo.

There, doctors have been working to restore Loughner to competency. Part of that treatment had been forcible medication; the state said it was needed because Loughner was presenting a danger to himself and others, but defense attorneys called it a backdoor attempt to drug Loughner back to competency.

With the initial four–month commitment expiring, the government is now asking for more time to work on Loughner. The doctor treating him at Springfield said she believes "an additional period of time will allow Mr. Loughner to improve and reach competency to stand trial," according to court documents.

But defense attorneys have argued in filings to Burns that there is no evidence of a "substantial probability" that Loughner will become competent to stand trial. They said the government needs to present such a finding, backed by evidence, in order for their client's commitment to be extended.

Patricia A. Zapf, a professor at the John Jay College of Criminal Justice, said the court should wait at least six months before even attempting to determine whether he will be restored to competency.

"It's a little too early to tell that he is incompetent and untreatable," she said.

Dean Aufderheide, president of the International Association for Correctional and Forensic Psychology, said that competency determinations have caused controversy because the conditions that make a person incompetent have not been specified.

There may be "conceptual confusion" when assessing competency "if there is a failure to properly apply the data of the clinical evaluation to the pertinent legal criteria," Aufderheide said.

He said the Supreme Court in 1960 defined competency as "a sufficient present ability to consult with one's attorney with a reasonable degree of ... rational, as well as factual understanding of legal proceedings against him."

In Loughner's case, Zapf said the court will be looking at his actions during the hearing as well as the medical records from the last 120 days at Springfield.

"The court is looking for whether a degree of disconnect is there," she said. The defendant needs the "capacity to perform" in what happens at the trial.

Joel Dvoskin, forensic psychologist at the University of Arizona, agreed with Slobogin that competency is a relatively low standard.

"You just have to understand what's going on and be able to help your lawyer," says Dvoskin.

He said defendants are presumed competent going in. If they are not competent, they are "acutely psychotic" which he called an "impaired ability to know what's real or not."

Aufderheide said he thinks the prosecution will not only want to continue to hold Loughner but also to continue treating him as they have been, including "the use of involuntary administration of medication."

Zapf said it is clear Loughner has a legitimate illness and "when he has been medicated he has shown improvements."

"So he should be medicated so he can improve and be competent to stand trial," she said.