Appeals court denies new hearing for double-murderer in Elfrida killings
A federal appeals court Monday denied Richard Dale Stokley's request for a new hearing in his 1991 conviction for the brutal murders of two 13-year-old girls near Elfrida in Cochise County.
A three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals rejected Stokley's claim that his trial lawyer did not adequately pursue a defense that he suffered from organic brain damage that clouded his judgment at the time of the murders.
"Although trial counsel's actions may seem imperfect in hindsight, counsel undertook an extensive investigation into Stokley's mental health, arranged for him to be evaluated by a neuropsychologist and presented testimony from a psychologist and neurologist," Judge Margaret M. McKeown wrote in the court's ruling.
Stokley did not show he had received constitutionally ineffective legal representation, said the opinion, which upheld a district court ruling denying him a new hearing on his mental capacity.
Stokley's attorney could not be reached for comment on the ruling Monday. An assistant attorney general for Arizona declined comment on the decision.
The case began on July 7, 1991, when Stokley was working as a stuntman in a Fourth of July celebration in Elfrida. According to court documents, Stokley told police that he had not bathed in almost a week and had asked Randy Brazeal to take him to a stock tank to take a bath.
On the way, they picked up two girls who had been camping with other children at the Fourth of July celebrations and who had been seen talking with Brazeal.
The next day, Brazeal turned himself in to Chandler police and turned his car over to them. Police found semen and blood stains, handprints and a bloody pair of men's pants in the car.
Stokley was arrested that day in Benson. Police found blood stains on his shoes and said his pants looked as if they had recently been cut off at the knee, according to court documents.
During questioning, Stokley said he and Brazeal had sexually assaulted the girls, killed them and dumped their bodies down an abandoned mine shaft, to which he later led investigators.
The girls had been choked, kicked, beaten and each was stabbed in the right eye. Footprints on the bodies matched Stokley's and Brazeal's shoes. DNA evidence showed that both men had sex with one of the girls; mud in the mine made it impossible to get conclusive results from tests on the other girl.
District court records said tests indicated that the killer had repeatedly relaxed and tightened his hands on the victims while strangling them.
"I ... choked 'em ... There was one foot moving though I knew they was brain dead but I was getting scared," Stokley told police, according to court documents. "They just wouldn't quit. It was terrible."
Brazeal pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and was sentenced to 20 years in prison. Stokley went to trial and was convicted in 1992 of two counts of kidnapping, one count of sexual conduct with a minor, and two counts of premeditated first-degree murder.
At his sentencing hearing, his attorney presented evidence from several doctors that Stokley suffered "multiple head injuries throughout his life," including being hit with a beer mug and a car jack, that caused brain damage and affected his ability to control his impulses. Another doctor diagnosed him with borderline personality disorder.
But the trial judge said the aggravating factors in the case - multiple homicides of minors in an "especially heinous, cruel, or depraved" manner - outweighed any mitigating circumstances, and sentenced Stokley to death.
In his latest appeal, Stokley argued that his attorney failed to follow the doctors' suggestion that "additional neuropsychological testing" was needed. But the district court denied that claim and the appeals court upheld the lower court Monday.
"Stokley ... claims that, despite counsel's emphasis on his mental health, counsel was required to order an entire battery of neuropsychological tests. We reject this argument," Judge McKeown wrote. "Counsel had no reason to believe the step would be necessary."
