U.S. Supreme Court denies last-chance appeal in Tuesday execution
WASHINGTON - The U.S. Supreme Court this morning refused to block the execution of an Illinois man who is scheduled to be put to death today after almost 23 years on Arizona's death row.
Justice Anthony M. Kennedy, without comment, denied two last-ditch appeals for a stay of execution for Thomas Paul West, who was convicted of murder in the "heinous" 1987 beating death of a Tucson-area man.
Kennedy rejected West's two most recent challenges. West had argued that his abusive childhood and the resulting post-traumatic stress disorder were not properly considered at his original trial. He also argued, with three other inmates currently on Arizona's death row, that the state's use of certain sedatives in the lethal injection procedure were unconstitutional.
Kennedy's ruling follows similar rejections Monday by both the Arizona Supreme Court and the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
West is scheduled to be put to death by lethal injection today at 11 a.m. at the Arizona state prison in Florence.
West, 52, was convicted for the July 1987 beating death of Don Bortle in Bortle's trailer outside of Tucson. According to court documents, West and a friend had visited Bortle to buy electronic goods; two weeks later, West returned to rob Bortle of those goods.
West beat Bortle, tied and gagged him and shoved him in a closet, where he left him before stealing the goods and Bortle's car. Medical experts testified the Bortle likely died within an hour from blunt-force trauma.
West claimed that he did not know that Bortle was dead, telling a friend that he had severely beaten "an old man" in the robbery. The friend turned West in to the Pima County Sheriff, who found Bortle's decomposing body five days after the beating.
West was arrested in Illinois after the car he was in was pulled over for speeding, and returned to Arizona where he was convicted in March 1988 of first-degree murder, second-degree burglary and theft. On Aug. 1, 1988, he was sentenced to death.
West would be Arizona's 91st inmate to be put to death since 1910 and the fourth this year. He will be put to death by lethal injection -- the 26th inmate in the state to be executed by that method.
The most recent execution was less than three weeks ago, when Richard Bible was put to death June 30 for the 1988 murder of a 9-year-old girl in Flagstaff.
