From corporate law to Guantanamo Bay: Valley attorney defends detainee
PHOENIX – For almost three years, attorney Howard Cabot commuted to work by catching a flight to Washington, D.C., hopping on a military plane to Guantanamo Bay and using a ferry to reach the prison camp holding his client, a Sudanese man accused of aiding terrorists.
As a longtime corporate litigation attorney with the firm of Perkins Coie LLP, Cabot deals primarily with companies, customers and the bottom line. But in 2008 that changed with a call from the Center for Constitutional Rights, a nonprofit legal advocacy organization based in New York City.
The center asked if he would consider filing pro bono court petitions of habeas corpus on behalf of detainees. Cabot viewed the offer as a kind of public service, he said – the need to help "not because it's profitable but because it's the right thing to do."
"I still feel the sting of 9/11," Cabot said. "[But] I also remember that I'm part of a nation of laws. And it's very important that, notwithstanding the difficult times we're in, we make sure we don't sacrifice the kind of values that make our country as special as it is."
By April 2008, Cabot knew he would represent Noor Uthman Muhammed, "better known in Guantanamo as No. 707," he said.
Noor faced charges of providing material support to terrorists, running a suspected terrorist camp and attending a meeting of al-Qaida officials before the 9/11 attacks. Noor would receive a trial by military commission and, if convicted, face a life sentence.
"Noor is really not someone who would fit the profile of an operational terrorist," Cabot said. "And the challenges are greater than I ever expected."
Just getting to his client involved arduous trips to Cuba, living in a one-room hut and security searches, he said.
"You really can't go to the prison camp for less than a week," he said. "Even if you're going to see him one or two times, it's a whole week."
Then there was communicating – difficult because Noor spoke a tribal dialect of Arabic that challenged even the camp's translators. And Cabot's upbringing starkly contrasted with Noor's impoverished background.
But as their hours together mounted and the case went before a military commission, Cabot said he developed a connection with his client.
"This was the first time that Noor had an opportunity to tell his story – to get it out there," Cabot said. "I got to be the teller of the story in the presence of my client after all these hours we spent together. It was a very emotional moment."
Ultimately, Cabot persuaded Noor to plead guilty in exchange for a reduced sentence of 14 years. And as part of his plea deal, Noor could be released in 34 months after providing testimony for use by future commissions and trials. Cabot finished his latest trip last week.
Cabot's son, Tyler, accompanied his father to Guantanamo Bay and has written several pieces for Esquire magazine about Noor's trial.
"There is an additional amount of stress when you're dealing with someone's life," Tyler Cabot said. "As a usual corporate attorney, this was something different for my father."
Howard Cabot said the stress and challenges of the experience changed his outlook on detainees.
"It heightens your sensitivity – makes you a more tolerant person, makes you want to listen more and makes you want to drill down on issues," he said.

Colton Shone

Channing Turner
