Skip to content

Proposition on land swaps too close to call

PHOENIX – A ballot measure that would allow Arizona to exchange state trust land for other public property was too close to call late Tuesday.

Unofficial returns showed Proposition 110, which is intended to preserve military bases and boost conservation through public land swaps, in a virtual tie even though the measure faced no formal opposition.

State Land Commissioner Maria Baier, a supporter of the proposition, said she was not surprised by the close vote, especially in a year of “grumpy voters.”

“Ballot propositions are viewed with a very high level of skepticism to begin with,” she said, expressing hope the measure would pass once all the votes are tallied.

“If we had a little more time on it, we could probably bring in more money and we could launch a more physical campaign,” Baier said. “I think this one’s doing well considering what kind of year it is.”

The measure addresses a 1990 Arizona Supreme Court ruling that prevents the State Land Department from exchanging trust land. The state, which manages trust land to benefit public education, currently must sell or lease such property.

Supporters of Proposition 110 said that current restriction for land swaps could interfere with efforts to prevent encroachment on military bases, such as Fort Huachuca near Sierra Vista in southern Arizona, as well as keep state trust land from being added to federal conservation areas.

Groups that have tangled in the past over land exchanges worked together to develop and support the ballot measure. Their plan included mechanisms for ensuring land proposed for exchange is of equal value and for getting public input. It also called for a statewide vote on any exchange.

Conservation groups including the Sierra Club Grand Canyon Chapter promoted the measure in large part because of its review and approval requirements.

Sandy Bahr, president of the Sierra Club Arizona chapter, was still optimistic for its passage, even though the complex measure was not an easy sell.

“It’s tough to get a constitutional amendment passed, especially one that is not easy to explain in a soundbite,” she said.

If the proposition is rejected, Bahr said she hopes military supporters and state legislators including Sen. John Nelson, R-Glendale, would again work with conservationists to facilitate the pubic land exchanges.

“The other way to do it is to name the specific lands and put it on the ballot, not just have this interim step,” she said.

The State Land Department currently manages about 9.2 million acres of trust land that the federal government granted Arizona upon statehood in 1912.

Gov. Jan Brewer, Baier and the League of Arizona Cities and Towns were among Proposition 110’s prominent supporters.

Proponents were primarily concerned about development interfering with and possibly endangering Arizona's military bases. They said swaps with the federal government could preserve military bases while providing Arizona valuable property that can be leased or sold to benefit public education.

In addition to swaps keeping development away from Fort Huachuca, where the Army tests communications equipment and trains intelligence officers, supporters said exchanges could guarantee flight paths into and out of Luke Air Force Base's auxiliary fields in Wittmann and Gila Bend.

In recent years, conservationists, developers, military leaders and state officials often were at odds over several proposed land exchanges - mostly over claims that the deals did not offer equal value. But the sides came together to develop and push for Proposition 110.