Three years after scandal, officials, residents point to improvements at veterans home
PHOENIX — Stuart Matthews, a Vietnam veteran, said he sees the changes in the care and the attention he and others receive at the Arizona State Veteran Home.
“I’ve been getting a lot more help; now I get my own shower person, I get my own nurse and my own social worker,” said Matthews, who has lived here since 2006.
State officials say the changes show in evaluations of the home and its care by state and federal agencies.
Three years after reports of rule violations and inadequate patient care led to the resignation of the head of the Arizona Department of Veterans’ Services, Matthews and others say care is significantly better, though not necessarily perfect.
During annual reviews of the 200-bed facility last year, the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs and the Arizona Department of Health Services acknowledged improvements in the quality and training of staff members, protocols for nurses, such as what to do when residents are injured, and a rapid response to correcting deficiencies.
“They’ve really improved, and that’s showing in the results that we’re finding,” said Alan Oppenheim, deputy assistant director of the Arizona Department of Health Services.
One of the biggest improvements, Oppenheim said, is establishing procedures so problems don’t reoccur.
“They are not just focusing on one issue,” he said. “They’re taking a look at it and seeing how that issue potentially could be spread; and they work to stop it from spreading.”
In 2007, not long after reports of neglect and unsanitary conditions at Walter Reed Army Medical Center made national headlines, the state Department of Health Services cited problems such as staff members ignoring call buttons and leaving residents in soiled clothing at the Arizona State Veteran Home. That review stemmed from complaints by residents and their relatives.
The federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services fined the state more than $10,000. Patrick F. Chorpenning, director of the Arizona Department of Veterans’ Services, later resigned.
Three years later, agency leaders point to changes made in response to those concerns, such as hiring better-qualified and better-paid employees and putting more emphasis on residents’ individual plans of care, said Homer Rodgers, the assistant deputy director who supervises the home.
“When you set systems in place, you make sure that the regulations are being maintained and they won’t fall out, and those systems are in place and strictly adhered to,” Rodgers said.
Matthews, who breathes oxygen from a tank, said that while things are better around the home there’s still room for improvement, such as getting rid of occasional long waits _ sometimes as long as 40 minutes _ for nurses to respond to his call button.
“When they don’t answer that call light they could be putting someone’s life in jeopardy,” he said.
Last year, licensing inspectors from the Arizona Department of Health Services investigated a complaint of neglect involving a resident who fell and fractured his hip.
The review found that a nurse failed to notify a physician and monitor and treat the patient after he complained about pain, an oversight that left the patient in pain for more than eight hours before being taken to a hospital and undergoing surgery. Officials from the home paid $500 in civil penalties.
As a result of that case, staff members now have to notify a physician, provide treatment and alert the resident’s physician and relatives or legal representatives, according to the case files.
Oppenheim, the department’s deputy assistant director, said that despite that incident there are fewer problems that endanger residents’ health.
During that same visit, the home received 34 citations, most of which involved management of residents’ medical documents.
In early 2008, the home was hit with a $4,125 fine by the Arizona Department of Health Services for a case of neglect that resulted in a resident having three toes amputated. The home responded by requiring nurses to closely supervise residents, according to the case documents.
A couple months later, the home was fined $1,000 by the Arizona Department of Health Services for discharging a resident who couldn’t care for himself. The home now requires nurses to adequately prepare residents to ensure they are safely transferred or discharged from the home, according to the case documents.
“We have made systemic approaches to make certain that these instances do not reoccur and that the home maintains in compliance,” said Rodgers, the assistant deputy director who supervises the home.
David M. Mobley, a Vietnam veteran who served almost 10 years in the Marine Corps and moved in after the problems of 2007, said staff members have done a good job helping him deal with post-traumatic stress disorder.
“I have been able to create a relationship with the staff; they know what they are doing and they are very caring toward me,” he said.

Griselda Nevarez

Griselda Nevarez
